Aris doesn't know much about Nifflers, but he's nearly positive that isn't standard Niffler behavior and he's entirely positive that the thing just played him. He throws the pizza box back into the creature's face as hard as he can (it won't hurt, but hey, it's an inconvenience, right?) and rushes back to join the others, putting himself between the girl holding the raccoon and the dumpster.

"What the heck is that?" And, more importantly, what're they supposed to do about it without their wands?